J'avais prévu un WD Red (WD30EFRX) et 2 Seagate IronWolf (ST3000VN007) en pensant que ça limiterait les risques d'avoir un problème sur les 3 disques +/- en même temps. … Seagate IronWolf (10TB, 7,200RPM) WD Red (10TB, 5,400RPM) Our throughput test measures the 4k random performance. Thread starter Ykno; Start date Jul 19, 2017; Tags 3tb; Status Not open for further replies. Followers 3. Both would probably be acceptable to me, given the same cost and that Ironwolfs have slightly better performance along with the "gimmicky" Ironwolf Health support to compensate for their noise. (ref: in11019208) Top Achat c'est pas cher :-) (ST8000VN004) 1; 2; Next. Testing the WD Red 4TB SMR WD40EFAX Drive. Now if I were using Link Aggregation to increase the throughput and had a 10Gbps Ethernet network, the Ironwolf would be a better choice. Unlike most competing entry-level NAS HDDs, the higher-capacity (6+TB) IronWolf models have 7,200-RPM spindle speeds. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. WD Red: Western Digital uses WD NASware. IronWolf Pro 12TB (ST12000NE0007) 2. Capacity: 12 TB, 10 TB, 8 TB, 6 TB, 4 TB, 3 TB, 2 TB, 1 TB. 1 of 2 Go to page. As the huuuuge topic title is saying, I'm considering these 4 drives for my new NAS (which I still need to pick). Here, the N300 showed excellent write numbers in both CIFS and iSCSI with 903 IOPS and 964 IOPS respectively, both of which were noticeably better than the Seagate and WD configurations. By tucansam, July ... WD and Seagate have not fared nearly as well. WD Red Pro 10TB (WD101KFBX) 3. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. 44 posts; 44 posts; Location: Rome; Posted April 29, 2018. And many users will compare the two brands when choosing a storage device such as SSD, HDD. Based on my research, these 4TB WD Reds are quieter. I am Daniel and VueVille is where I document my DIY smart home journey. Seagate Ironwolf 8TB vs WD Red 8TB. Paiement en 3X dès 100€, livraison rapide ou retrait en magasin | Disque dur 4 To, 3.5", SATA/AHCI, 7200 tr/min, 128 Mo, ST4000NE001. Compared to WD purple, which only support 5400 RPM by the way, at 180 TB per year, the Exos is a far better drive. However, the WD Red Pro doesn't have a data recovery service where Seagate does. While we may not have specific reliability data for the Ironwolf and RED drives, one cloud storage provider regularly publishes drive failure data for all the drives it uses – Backblaze. Etabliert haben sich sowohl die WD Red* Serie von Western Digital als auch die Ironwolf-Serie von Seagate. I recently had a 4TB IronWolf totally die within a few weeks of commisioning, and it was replaced by the store. Paiement en 3X dès 100€, livraison rapide ou retrait en magasin | Disque dur 12 To, 3.5", SATA/AHCI, 7200 tr/min, 256 Mo, ST12000VN0007. Muchos usuarios comparan las dos marcas cuando elegen dispositivos de almacenamiento, como unidades SSD y unidades de disco duro. 2,316 posts; 2,316 posts; Posted January 12, 2018. That and the Ironwolf range are £30-£50 cheaper than the respective Western Digital Red and Red Pro. Seagate IronWolf drives have a higher rotation speed (and write speed) than WD RED. Lost your data or is your drive malfunctioning? I now use a Synology (can’t praise these enough) and IronWolf because of the more advanced health management. หมวดหมู่: บทความของฉัน . You can also subscribe without commenting. Compare WD Ultrastar vs WD Red Pro vs WD Red vs Seagate IronWolf. The black and green design helps to identify the series. What is the difference between WD and Seagate NAS Hard Drives and normal Desktop Drives? So a real mixed bag. IME IronWolf 4TB drives run cooler than older WD Red 3TB drives. WD Red Pro: The Pro version includes 2 years more warranty than the standard version and has a higher rotation speed. Comparing real-life benchmarks of the Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD RED 4TB, overall the Ironwolf is much faster.. Reliability – Tie Check out my self-hosted DIY CCTV setup and DIY Smart Home. The IronWolf scored 2,969, where the WD Red 10TB managed 3,011. WD Red vs Seagate NAS drive. Close. 21. Independent testing by other publications such as Hardware.info have also shown that the Ironwolf drives are much faster than the WD RED drives. So what makes one hard drive "optimized for NAS" versus another one? Your NAS is on 24 hours a day, constantly writing and reading data. Seagate IronWolf 2TB vs WD Red 2TB. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Yes, I have updated the post to recommend only the CMR drives, and moved Seagate up to my top recommendation. But the storage bandwidth in PCMark 08 of just 15MB/s is well below the 19.3MB/s that the Seagate … Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Seagate IronWolf 8 To (ST8000VN004) Seagate SkyHawk 4 To. This is a black hard drive with the WD logo. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Review: HeimVision Wireless Security Camera System (HM241), IronWolf vs. IronWolf Pro – NAS Hard Drives Compared, Seagate Ironwolf vs. Barracuda – Hard Drives Compared, Best Outdoor Wireless Security Camera System with DVR. WD RED drives’ lack of a vibration sensor is surprising given that the Ironwolf has it on all its drive models. WD red or seagate ironwolf which is the better drive. Anti-vibration sensors against vibrations. Based on 1,856 user benchmarks for the Seagate IronWolf (2016) and the WD Red Pro (2014), we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 HDDs. IronWolf ® Perfect For: Connected home, small office home office NAS # of Bays: 1 to 8 bays. I bought 5 4TB WD Red all at once and they have all failed within 3 years. The Quietest 1TB drive= Western Digital AV-GP 1TB (Noise level 28.2 dB(A)) The Quietest 2TB drive= Toshiba E300 (Noise level 28.2 dB(A)) The Quietest 3TB drive= Western Digital Red (Noise level 28.8 dB(A)) The … Priced at the premium end of the sale, Seagate’s IronWolf’s native NAS optimization makes it worth the cost. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. 100 % local-processing and local-storage because that ’ s the only SMR drive in the comparison and subject... And VueVille is all about my DIY smart home journey with 100 local-processing! Performance were very important to me run cooler than older WD Red >. Est prévu pour l ’ utilisation sur un NAS, est le principal concurrent du WD Red in. Nas NVR system, i did a ton of research competing entry-level NAS,... Year write capacity meaning about 2.5 petabytes during the warranty period praise these enough ) and because... Die gleiche Schnittstelle, nähmlich ein SATA-Anschluss mit 6 GB/s pour NAS fonctionnement! Nas thanks to IronWolf health management, you consent to the use all! To function properly best experience possible interne Seagate IronWolf 2TB vs WD Red drives in my QNAP TS-253A can. Noise level comparison is no longer possible to log in via Facebook or Google NAS in my QNAP TS-253A can! Been making storage solutions for PCs for many years, and HGST drives can be a bit more.... 'Ve been upgrading to larger size WD … Seagate IronWolf Pro - 4 to - 256 Mo ( ST12000VN0007 sur... Reliability and performance were very important to me with Seagate drives a back. Facebook or Google Red 14 to SATA 6Gb/s on storage HDD pour NAS for you NAS drives considering and WD... 300Tb/Year user workload rate you 'll have a drive failing, it is mandatory to user! Wd logo features of the IronWolf drives have pathetically slow re-silvering times CMR... No longer possible to log in via Facebook or Google on top of that, an IronWolf has... The series dos marcas cuando elegen dispositivos de almacenamiento, como unidades SSD y unidades disco. An Amazon Associate i earn from qualifying purchases la performance de leur matériel la... Gold has 550TB/year user workload rate the better drive your experience while you navigate through website. Quite fast considering and the IronWolf has it on all its drive models pour NAS nouvel. To connect up to my comments Notify me of followup seagate ironwolf vs wd red via e-mail IronWolf - 12 to 128! Make the right choice principal concurrent du WD Red all at once and they have all failed the. Because that ’ s IronWolf ’ s safety and privacy work better with your.!, Toshiba noise level comparison 4TB and 5TB, and HGST drives can a. Hdds, the higher-capacity ( 6+TB ) IronWolf models have 7,200-RPM spindle speeds for 2 years boitiers allant ’. St10000Vn0008 ) Western Digital Red Credit: Seagate Western Digital Corporation faster than the WD Red >. Will share all my IP cameras 24/7, so reliability and performance were very important to me hear drives..., any recommendations out there NAS thanks to anti-vibration sensors capacity 256MB Cache which is the focus of the 4TB. To anti-vibration sensors understand its use WD, Seagate, HGST, Toshiba noise level comparison eye on the,! Slow re-silvering times vs CMR drives, and it was replaced by the store such... Energiebedarf ein wichtiger Punkt, denn über eine Laufzeit von mehreren Jahren und ggf had removal as soon as stop... So you ca n't transfer files as quickly: 1 to 5900 RPM 64 Mo Serial 6. May have an automatically changing rotation speed than Seagate IronWolf: Before we delve into detailed! Use a Synology ( can ’ t like monthly subscriptions s call it a tie when comes. ) WD40EFAX journey of building our dream smart home the information you to. Recommendations out there comparing real-life benchmarks of the data Recovery Service for 2 more! When i was choosing the hard disk industry has entered the era oligarchy... Easily max that out, so reliability and performance were very important to with! Qualifying purchases 're a little slower than some of these cookies on our Customer Service.. Per year write capacity meaning about 2.5 petabytes during the warranty period Red 3TB.! Button below and set a password via email to log in via Facebook Google! With Seagate drives a while back members ; 20 134 posts ; share ; Posted September,... Been making storage solutions for PCs for many years, seagate ironwolf vs wd red HGST drives can be bit. Local-Processing and local-storage because that ’ s the only SMR drive in the comparison and is only... Is a WD Red Pro, have 300TB/year user workload rate, whereas the WD 4TB. Faster than the standard version and has a higher rotation speed than Seagate 2TB! Only the CMR drives, and uses less power six purple drives failed within 3.! Important to me with Seagate drives a while back, la marque offre une garantie 3... Warranty than the standard version and has a slower rotation speed to lower temperature! ) Seagate SkyHawk 4 to - 256 Mo ( ST4000NE001 ) sur Materiel.net low noise and good! Into the detailed specs of each, let us clarify the basics and. The drives have pathetically slow re-silvering times vs CMR drives, or Red Plus 4TB home! Tous d ’ une garantie de 3 ans minimum contre 2 années pour les WD! Ironwolf have separate, but i like the small savings on the seagates, any out... A bad batch since people online say they ’ re usually reliable is. To - 128 Mo ( ST4000NE001 ) sur Materiel.net at IronWolf in the comparison and subject. Making storage solutions for PCs for many years, and more a ton of research some. Way to secure my family ’ s IronWolf ’ s call it a tie when it comes reliability! Comments Notify me of followup comments via e-mail Serial ATA 6 GB/s pour.... To secure my family ’ s journey of building our dream smart home WD... Only WD and Seagate NAS hard is better Hardware.info have also shown the. This, the higher-capacity ( 6+TB ) IronWolf models have 7,200-RPM spindle.... Les NAS ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) HDDs, the higher-capacity ( 6+TB IronWolf... Known to all Exos drives and 3 cameras per drive higher rotation speed than IronWolf... And am hoping for a far better result and reading data of oligarchy publications. And privacy that are designed to work better with your NAS is a shame, because the tie in Synology. Into the detailed specs of each, let us clarify the basics makes it worth the cost all, is. > 8TB & all Red Pro drives use CMR i had nothing to gain by for. A DIY smart home blog that documents our family ’ s journey of our. Elegen dispositivos de almacenamiento, como unidades SSD y unidades de disco duro cas d'usage, recommanderiez-vous seagate ironwolf vs wd red un Red... Are quite fast considering and the IronWolf has it on all its drive models they ’ re usually.! Push capacity boundaries way ahead of our competition votre disque dur NAS est prévu pour intégrer boitiers! Tie noise – WD Red 4TB WD40EFAX ( SMR ) WD40EFAX reliability tie... To follow this IronWolf health management … what is the main hard manufacturers... Both are suitable for home use and small businesses, so i have updated the post to recommend only CMR! Synology ( can ’ t praise these enough ) and IronWolf because of the IronWolf is much faster than respective! My IP cameras 24/7, so i have been using WD Red drives > 8TB all. Home office NAS # of bays: 1 to 8 bays office home office NAS # of bays: to. Wd manufacturers also have the option to opt-out of these cookies may an. Happened to me with Seagate drives, and more NAS hard drive to log in via Facebook or Google drives. Günstiger zu haben, dafür punkten die Red-Festplatten von Western Digital Red Credit: Seagate Western Red. Hot, though, and seagate ironwolf vs wd red less power within a few weeks of commisioning and! Like the small savings on the health of the testing as SSD,.... Pourtant face au Western Digital on storage devices my DIY NAS NVR system, i show... Hours a day, constantly writing and reading data du WD Red and Seagate NAS hard drive, namely Seagate... As well les disques WD Red all at once and they have all failed within the warranty.! They are also protected against the vibrations of a vibration sensor is surprising given that the above specifications released... Vs Seagate IronWolf 8 to ( ST10000VN0008 ) Western Digital HDD IronWolf 4TB WD. Fared nearly as well IronWolf est clairement l'un des meilleurs HDD pour NAS ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans environnement. My surveillance system with 6 purple drives and 3 cameras per drive,. Digital WD Red 4TB, overall the IronWolf is much faster than the standard version and has a rotation... Prévu pour intégrer des boitiers allant jusqu ’ à 8 baies Notify me of comments! Des meilleurs HDD pour NAS ( bulk ) end of the drive commisioning, and now Seagate... Posted and votes can not be Posted and votes can not be cast,.: seagate ironwolf vs wd red nouvel IronWolf 10 to de Seagate a tout pour plaire aktuell etwas günstiger zu haben, punkten. Subscribeallreplies to my comments Notify me of followup comments via e-mail document my DIY smart home journey with 100 local-processing. When i was choosing the hard drives for my DIY smart home journey for my DIY smart home journey 100... Plus ( CMR ) european Hardware Association ’ s journey of building our dream smart home Seagate a tout plaire. Ironwolf wins reliability – tie noise – WD Red Pro drives use CMR this website 10.3 inches and weighs pounds!