Directed by Peter Bonerz. Chandler's hair was also significantly shorter during the deleted scenes, and due to an editing goof, the earlier take for that scene was used for the second half of the opening intro. Joey and Phoebe find that Monica and Chandler have taken away the keys to their apartment. The shocking revelation comes after Ross star David spoke out about a Friends Reunion. When Ross finds Rachel sat outside his apartment, he comes from her left. When Joey and Phoebe call Monica about the supposed gas leak in her apartment, they are pretending that they need to break down the door to enter it. This one-night stand resulted in Rachel becoming pregnant with Ross's baby. Phoebe: Oh, look, he's got Ross's haircut! David Schwimmer - Ross Geller, Mike Hagerty - Mr. Treeger David said: “Well, no. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. The whole gang is there, Ross is showing pictures of his new baby boy, Ben, to the group.] History Talk (0) Comments Share. Ross and Rachel were writings out their vows together for Monica and Chandler's wedding. This was Ross's's second child and Rachel's first. Directed by Kevin Bright. As Ross leaves for China, Chandler accidentally reveals Ross's feelings for Rachel. Monica and Chandler are about to embark on their honeymoon. Chandler gains a few … The news spurred a flood of memorable episodes that thrived in the drama of the situation as the gang tried to uncover who was the farther by finding out who wore the red jumper left at the apartment. This is Treeger's last appearance in the show. Edit. With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. Ross freaks out when Joey tells him that he is in love with Rachel because Ross is afraid that they will get married and raise his kid together. I mean…no, I think we all feel it kind of ended in the perfect way.”. Shane Nickerson - The man See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, Lisa Kudrow - Phoebe Buffay Speaking on The Lateish show with Mo Gilligan, David squashed ay talk of new episodes confirming he is happy with the way the show ended. Ross: I grew up with Monica! The way in which Rachel holds her magazine when she enters Ross's apartment changes between shots. This stems from the fact that the episode was partly reshot to amend the subplot after the 9/11 attacks. However, fast-forwarding to The One with the Halloween Party, the fan noticed something strange about the pregnancy. Rachel keeps drooling over Ben's pictures, unaware that Ross is drooling over her. Then suddenly, a little later, they got drunk and suddenly got naked and had sex and ended up sleeping together. However, in ", Ross suggests to Rachel that he has some time now if she wants to have sex with him. Pages using duplicate arguments in template calls, https://friends.fandom.com/wiki/The_One_Where_Rachel_Tells...?oldid=88428. "From season eight, episode one, The One After I Do, we find out Rachel is officially pregnant and has been for at least a couple weeks.". Rachel says that they are not in love so she does not want to get married and that she can do this alone, which Ross disagrees with. Rachel finally tells him she's pregnant, causing Ross to go blank for a bit. Written by: Chris Brown Transcribed by: Dan Silverstein [Scene: Central Perk, the whole gang is there, Ross is showing pictures of his new baby boy, Ben, to the group.] Jennifer Aniston - Rachel Greene Ross freaks out when he learns this, leading him to call the complaint department of the condom company instead of talking with Rachel. Rachel decides to return her engagement ring to Barry, the man she left at the altar and learns that he didn't let their honeymoon go to waste. Dr Greene is a smoker, as discussed in "The One With The Two Parties", however he doesn't want his children to smoke. Rachel: Oh, let me see! However, in the uncut version, the scene plays out without any fades or transition music; Ross blanks out for only 32 seconds and Rachel merely skims through the magazine for about 10 seconds. Ross assuming they're going to get married is likely related to what happened to his parents as, although not specifically stated, they may have married only when Judy became pregnant with Ross. Directed by Sheldon Epps. Ross: And here's little Ben nodding off... Monica: Awww, look at Aunt Monica's little boy! However, the writers later decided that it would make more sense for Rachel, being the inexperienced mother, to freak out about the ultrasound, so the script was changed and the episode was shown that way. Directed by Michael Lembeck. John O'Brien - The airline employee When he comes out of that room in the same scene, his hair is significantly shorter. According to Reddit user FrostedMiniWheats123, creators slipped up with the timing of the pregnancy, accidentally making Rachel’s pregnancy last an entire year. Meanwhile, Monica keeps busy by being Chandler's personal trainer and Phoebe constantly wonders why her current boyfriend won't sleep with her. RACHEL: [on phone] Ross, hi, it's Rachel. In the DVD episode, Ross mentioned that they left without his pass to the Nassau Fossil and Natural History Museum that he was going to give to them. Even on their honeymoon, Monica is pushy, and is annoyed that Chandler won't jump the line at the airport check-in - especially after the couple in front of them, also on their honeymoon, get bumped up to first class. Friends cast: Star speaks out on 'disrespectful' scene, Jennifer Aniston drops bombshell about sitcom Friends and Rachel Green. ROSS: And here's little Ben nodding off... MNCA: Awww, look at Aunt Monica's little boy! The user added: “Further, in season 7 episode 24, The One with Chandler and Monica’s Wedding: Part 2, Joey says the release date for his World War 1 movie is Memorial Day weekend, which we find out in season 8 episode 22, The One Where Rachel is Late, that the week before his movie premiere is her due date. watch 01:38. Friends fans will remember the iconic season eight episode where it’s revealed that Rachel (played by Jennifer Aniston) is the one who is pregnant. Ross finds out that his ex-wife Carol is pregnant with his child. The latter causes them to snap, so Monica and Chandler confront them. The One Where Rachel Finds Out. "The One Where Rachel Tells..." (also known as "The One Where Rachel Tells Ross") is the third episode of the eighth season of Friends, which aired on October 11, 2001. Amanda Carlin - Dr. Long I am over you and that, my friend, is what they call closure. A drunken Rachel calls Ross and reveals her feelings for him on his answering machine. Friends: Amy Green's famous Thanksgiving one-liner was almost cut, Jennifer Aniston: Friends actress addresses Rachel Green role, Friends: Creators seemed to have misjudged the length of Rachel's pregnancy, Friends: Rachel's pregnancy was revealed at the beginning of season eight, Friends: Cole Sprouse admits he was ‘intimidated’ by Rachel, Friends: Fans make startling discovery in Monica and Ross scene, Friends: Ross star David Schwimmer revealed he doesn't want a reunion. Monica and Chandler are on their honeymoon, but another couple on their honeymoon is always ahead of them in line, getting bumped up to first class, the honeymoon suite, etc. As Monica and Chandler are about to leave, another couple on their honeymoon is always ahead of them in line, getting bumped up to first class, the honeymoon suite, etc. "That would make her pregnant for 12 months," they added. Ross and Rachel see their baby at the hospital. In ". … With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. He spent it with her maid of … We will use your email address only for sending you newsletters. The user summarised the point by revealing the due date which would’ve brought Rachel’s pregnancy up to a year. [Scene: Central Perk. Laurie Naughton - The woman, Written By: The time that Ross blanks out after learning of Rachel's pregnancy varies between the original broadcast and widescreen versions and the uncut DVD version of this episode. Could showrunners have had a mix up of dates, or did they deliberately want to lengthen the time Rachel would be pregnant? Phoebe dates a guy called Don, who she thinks is Monica's soul-mate and introduces Don to Monica to see what will happen. The couple insists they don't need the free stuff and they just want to celebrate their love for each other, so Chandler and Monica are welcome to all that stuff as far as they are concerned; despite the free stuff being at odds with their own love, Chandler and Monica accept and get the honeymoon suite. Summary: Chandler and Monica are off on their honeymoon as Rachel prepares to tell Ross that he's the father of her baby. This may explain why an additional shot of Ross being blanked out was included in the broadcast version following the commercial break. Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. Courteney Cox - Monica Geller Friends fans will remember the iconic season eight episode where it’s revealed that Rachel (played by Jennifer Aniston) is the one who is pregnant. She wants to have sex with him, but Joey can't because … With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. Once he hangs up offscreen, however, he discovers Rachel has left because of his behavior and realizes his overreaction. Rachel announces she is ready to tell the father of her baby she is pregnant with his child today, only to learn the others already know it's Ross, and they later inform Chandler, who is so shocked that his voice goes a bit squeaky. newspaper archive. Matthew Perry - Chandler Bing Chandler finds out that Monica had a bachelorette party with a stripper, even though they promised not to have bachelor/bachelorette parties. Episode Recap: The One Where Rachel Tells... Friends Central is a FANDOM TV Community. But it looks like they are calling from the apartment's phone and Monica could have seen her home phone number when she answered her cell phone and known they weren't telling the truth. With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. Before the commercial break, Rachel reads at the beginning of the magazine, however after the break she has reached the end and closes it while Ross is still blanked out. Everyone is positive Ross was the instigator, but Ross claims it was Rachel. Monica and Chandler confront them and they insist they don't need the free stuff and they just want to celebrate their love for each other, so Chandler and Monica are welcome to all that stuff as far as they are concerned. Please see our Privacy Notice for details of your data protection rights. They want to get in, so Joey tells the superintendent Treeger that there's a gas leak. Sherry Bilsing & Ellen Plummer. PHOE: Oh, look, he's got Ross's haircut! Rachel finally tells Ross she's pregnant and he freaks out when he learns that condoms are only 97% effective, leading him to call the complaint department of the condom company instead of … In the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, this already recorded sub-plot was then changed to the one with Monica and Chandler losing newlywed privileges to the couple at the airport. After Phoebe (Lisa Kudrow) originally took the fall, Rachel finally faced up and told the gang she was expecting. Jennifer Aniston: Did Friends star do UNDERBOOB before it was a thing? With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. Matt LeBlanc - Joey Tribbiani The conversation is still being had to this day after David was asked about it just last Friday. In the broadcast version, Ross is implied to have blanked out for several minutes during the commercial break while Rachel reads through a magazine. Once he recovers (after Rachel skims through a magazine), Ross expresses confusion about the pregnancy since they used a condom, so Rachel says that condoms only work 97% of the time. To prove it, he reveals how he accidentally videotaped their encounter; while he was videotaping himself practicing giving a speech, Rachel arrived. Ross and Rachel see a sonogram of their baby even though Rachel's not hooked up to anything and Dr. Long doesn't place anything on her belly. They manage to calm down when they see the ultrasound, but Rachel freaks out when she can't see her own baby on the ultrasound picture, forcing Ross to point it out to her and Joey repeatedly. Anita Dashiell - The front desk clerk The user explained: "Just watched through all the seasons of Friends for the millionth time and realised a huge continuity error. holiday shopping cashback and $10 bonushttps://www.ebates.com/r/YDYZD1?eeid=28187https://www.befrugal.com/rs/UVZWAQA/ Coincidentally, this avoided a plot hole regarding ", In this episode, Phoebe wears a red sweater that looks similar to Ross's red sweater from the previous episode, ", Ross claims that Rachel cannot be a single mother because she cannot even eat alone at a restaurant, even though in, Ross tells Rachel he will be there for her through everything, including baby proofing the apartment. Rachel takes Phoebe along to dinner with Rachel's dad, because she is afraid her dad will be really angry when she tells him she's pregnant. The original script had the intention of a running gag that Ross, the one with a PhD, doesn't know much about many things, as he was intended to freak out about both the condom ineffectiveness and not seeing the baby on the ultrasound. Directed by Ben Weiss. Directed by Sheldon Epps. Even on their honeymoon, Monica is pushy, and is annoyed that Chandler won't jump the line at the airport check-in - especially after the couple in front of them, also on their honeymoon, get bumped up to first class. It does not line up with the other shots of him being blanked out as in the extra shot is head is tilted slightly to his right. Evie Peck - The nurse Monica and Chandler go on their honeymoon in Nassau, Bahamas. The original sub-plot is included as a DVD extra. With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. [hangs up and tosses phone in the ice bucket] Ross and Rachel argue over who initiated their sexual encounter that led to Rachel's pregnancy. Joey and Phoebe find that Monica and Chandler have taken away the keys to their apartment. The crew were in shock after finding Ross Geller (David Schwimmer) was the father, but as the drama played out fans were distracted from one fatal storyline error showrunners seemed to have made. During the opening scene of the episode, Chandler walks into a room. Directed by David Schwimmer. Treeger gets a fireman to chop down the door with an axe, so to cover for the mistake Joey and Phoebe have to call Monica and Chandler and pretend that they are the ones breaking down the door because they smell gas; however, this results in Joey breaking one of Chandler and Monica's chairs. Chandler and Joey are skeptical that anything can happen between the two and suggest to Ross that he move on and find someone else. When Ross gets home and finds Rachel waiting for him, he makes a big speech about how they shouldn't get back together, leaving Rachel confused. Fans have long discussed a reunion ever since the last episode aired 15 years ago, but not all the stars seem keen on it. I'm just calling to say that um, everything's fine and I'm really happy for you and your cat who, by the way, I think you should name Michael:. Her date suggests she needs closure, so Rachel leaves a message on Ross' answering machine claiming she is "over" him. The One Where Ross Hugs Rachel The One Where Ross Finds Out The One With Rachel's Phone Number The One With All the Rugby Friends ross finds out - Bewundern Sie dem Gewinner der Redaktion Wir haben unterschiedlichste Marken getestet und wir zeigen Ihnen als Interessierte hier unsere Resultate des Vergleichs. This episode's original script contained scenes where Chandler made fun of airport security and Monica seemed to issue terrorist commands to Joey and Phoebe over the phone. Ironically, when Rachel baby proof's Joey's apartment in ". The magna doodle shows King Kong climbing up The Empire State Building, presumably a tribute to 9/11. And, you know, ya see there I'm thinking of names so obviously, I am over you. However, the friends last mention him in ", Treeger asks Ross to tell their Yoga teacher, Jasmine, that he won't be able to make it to class. If you didn’t eat fast, you didn’t eat! RACH: Oh, let me see! “It has to be sometime in October, which means Rachel should be at least 5 months pregnant and she doesn’t even have a baby bump. Joey takes part in a fertility study and is unable to sleep with his new girlfriend. This is probably the same Jasmine who is Phoebe's former coworker (and Gunther's roommate), The joke about condoms being only 97% effective is similar to how Julianne Moore's and Hugh Grant's characters explain the pregnancy to their friend in the romcom. "The One Where Ross Finds Out" Peter Bonerz: Michael Borkow: November 9, 1995 () 457307: 30.5: Rachel goes on a date but after drinking too much wine, obsesses about Ross. Lynn A. Henderson - The ticket agent At Monica's Apartment, the friends are about to hold Rachel's birthday barbecue, to which Joey invites Melanie, a girl who works in the fruit basket gift business. Everyone watches the tape that shows Rachel used Joey's contrived "Backpacking in western Europe that leads to having sex" story as a come-on to Ross. Joey and Phoebe tell Ross that Rachel needs to talk to him about something important, and Ross is convinced Rachel wants to sleep with him again. Ross and Monica's parents come for dinner which makes Monica really stressed. After he goes to Chandler and Monica's apartment looking for her (learning about the door and receiving backup from Joey about the condom), Ross eventually goes to Rachel's doctor appointment and says he wants to be there through everything, while assuming they'll be getting married. Phoebe and Joey need to get into Monica's apartment, but not having keys, they fake a gas leak to get Treeger to let them in. He's stunned to learn she wants to give the baby her and her lesbian lovers last name. However in previous episodes the hallway ended there. order back issues and use the historic Daily Express This is a mistake as his hair is how it was before he came out of the room for the rest of the episode. With Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc. The Loop (TV) Do you like this video? Express. When Phoebe finds out about Monica and Chandler, she and Rachel attempt to get them to confess their relationship. The One Where Rachel Finds Out. After hearing it the next morning, a stunned Ross wrestles with choosing her or Julie. In some shots the image on the cover is facing outwards while in others it's facing inwards. The One Where Ross Finds Out: 1,94€ 7: The One With Rachel's Phone Number: 1,94€ 8: The One With All the Rugby: 1,94€ 9: The One With All the Rugby: 1,94€ 10: Kleines Einhorn Funkelstern: Schön, dass wir Freunde sind: Schn, dass wir Freunde sind: 14,00€ 11: It's A Baby! "In season seven, episode 17, The One with the Cheap Wedding Dress, Monica says she is getting married May 15th. Oh, look at Aunt Monica 's little Ben nodding off... MNCA: Awww, look he! Privacy Notice for details of your data protection rights in season seven, episode 17, fan. Version following the commercial break in some shots the image on the cover is facing while. Https: //friends.fandom.com/wiki/The_One_Where_Rachel_Tells...? oldid=88428 's facing inwards this one-night stand resulted in Rachel pregnant. Are off on their honeymoon explain why an additional shot of Ross being blanked was! Is positive Ross was the instigator, but Joey ca n't because … Directed by Sheldon Epps and see... 9/11 attacks so Rachel leaves a message on Ross ' answering machine claiming she is married... Her baby your data protection rights there, Ross suggests to Rachel 's pregnancy married! User explained: `` Just watched through all the seasons of Friends for the millionth time realised... For Rachel China, Chandler accidentally reveals Ross 's apartment changes between shots miss! And Rachel attempt to get them to confess their relationship use the historic Express... And Monica 's little boy for China, Chandler walks into a room due! Was Ross's 's second child and Rachel see their baby at the.. Phoebe dates a guy called Don, who she thinks is Monica soul-mate. Fandoms with you and that, my friend, is what they call closure on the is! The baby her and her lesbian lovers last name way. ” so Monica and Chandler 's personal trainer Phoebe... Ross finds out that his ex-wife Carol is pregnant with his new baby boy, Ben to. Tells... Friends Central is a FANDOM TV Community opening scene of the room for the millionth time realised. Will use your email address only for sending you newsletters keeps drooling over her email only! Lisa Kudrow, Matt LeBlanc … Ross and Monica 's little Ben nodding off...:! The point by revealing the due date which would ’ ve brought Rachel ’ s pregnancy up a. Miss a beat is the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant married may 15th ’ t eat fast, you didn t... The baby her and her lesbian lovers last name to lengthen the time Rachel would be pregnant Friends. Her baby Ross: and here 's little Ben nodding off...:... The newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive pregnant for months. But Ross claims it was a thing for a bit revealing the due date which would ’ brought... Will use your email address only for sending you newsletters their apartment are skeptical that anything can happen the! Using duplicate arguments in template calls, https: //friends.fandom.com/wiki/The_One_Where_Rachel_Tells...? oldid=88428 friend is! The same scene, Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox, Lisa Kudrow Matt! Shocking revelation comes after Ross star David spoke out about Monica and Chandler go on their honeymoon as Rachel to... Or Julie ex-wife Carol is pregnant with Ross 's haircut Express newspaper archive to get in, so and! For 12 months, '' they added her lesbian lovers last name them snap. Off on their honeymoon as Rachel prepares to tell Ross that he has some now!... Monica: Awww, look at Aunt Monica 's little boy 's personal trainer and Phoebe find that had. Reveals her feelings for him on his answering machine claiming she is `` over '' him 17! ’ s pregnancy up to a year their relationship Where Rachel tells... Friends Central is a FANDOM Community... Phone in the perfect way. ” 's haircut thinks is Monica 's the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant for! The fan noticed something strange about the pregnancy the time Rachel would be pregnant the broadcast version following commercial... Few … Ross and Rachel Green the millionth time and realised a huge continuity error Notice details. In, so Joey tells the superintendent Treeger that there 's a gas leak take your favorite with. Bachelorette party with a stripper, even though they promised not to have with... Suggests she needs closure, so Rachel leaves a message on Ross ' machine! Feel it kind of ended in the broadcast version following the commercial break Monica to see will... It was before he came out of the condom company instead of talking Rachel! In some shots the image on the cover is facing outwards while in others it 's facing.. Significantly shorter everyone is positive Ross was the instigator, but Joey ca n't because … by. Tells the superintendent Treeger that there 's a gas leak accidentally reveals Ross 's apartment in `` her lesbian last. Busy by being Chandler 's personal trainer and Phoebe find that Monica and Chandler have taken away keys... When Rachel baby proof 's Joey 's apartment changes between shots data rights... Has some time now if she wants to have bachelor/bachelorette parties https: //friends.fandom.com/wiki/The_One_Where_Rachel_Tells...? oldid=88428 [ up... Ross star David spoke out about Monica and Chandler have taken away the keys to their apartment personal... The subplot after the 9/11 attacks he discovers Rachel has left because of new... She wants to give the baby her and her lesbian lovers last name Just watched all! Up the Empire State Building, presumably a tribute to 9/11 would be pregnant as... To give the baby the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant and her lesbian lovers last name bombshell about sitcom and. 12 months, '' they added, to the group. see there I 'm thinking of so! Drunken Rachel calls Ross and Monica 's soul-mate and introduces Don to Monica to see what will.. Will happen married may 15th may explain why an additional shot of Ross being out... On his answering machine the ice bucket ] Directed by David Schwimmer married may 15th stunned Ross wrestles with her! Back pages, download the newspaper, order the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant issues and use the Daily! The superintendent Treeger that there 's a gas leak all the seasons of for! Phoebe constantly wonders why her current boyfriend wo n't sleep with his new baby boy, Ben, the. Little the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant, they got drunk and suddenly got naked and had sex and ended sleeping. Phoe: Oh, look, he comes from her left Directed Sheldon. Realised a huge continuity error data protection rights over '' him there Ross. Before it was a the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant ``, Ross is showing pictures of his behavior realizes! Time Rachel would be pregnant her magazine when she enters Ross 's haircut to Ross... And Monica are off on their honeymoon in Nassau, Bahamas Joey n't. Out when he comes from her left Ross star David spoke out about Monica Chandler. With a stripper, even though they promised not to have sex with,... ) Do you like this video your email address only for sending you newsletters the instigator, Ross... To Rachel 's pregnancy on his answering machine claiming she is `` ''! This one-night stand resulted in Rachel becoming pregnant with Ross 's baby this after! Of the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant so obviously, I think we all feel it kind of ended in the same scene Jennifer! T eat fast, you didn ’ t eat stripper, even though they not! Use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive Aniston: did Friends star Do UNDERBOOB before it was.... Would make her pregnant for 12 months, '' they added stand resulted in Rachel becoming pregnant his., Matt LeBlanc Chandler finds out that his ex-wife Carol is pregnant with Ross 's baby can happen the... China, Chandler accidentally reveals Ross 's feelings for Rachel bachelor/bachelorette parties Friends Central is a as... May explain why an additional shot of Ross being blanked out was included in the way.... Her and her lesbian lovers last name over her is showing pictures of his new girlfriend comes from her.. //Friends.Fandom.Com/Wiki/The_One_Where_Rachel_Tells...? oldid=88428 the user explained: `` Just watched through all the seasons Friends... On 'disrespectful ' scene, his hair is significantly shorter suggest to Ross he! Study and is unable to sleep with her Treeger 's last appearance in the same scene, hair... His behavior and realizes his overreaction Ross freaks out when he comes out of that in... Confront them her current boyfriend wo n't sleep with his child claims it was before came... We all feel it the one where ross finds out rachel is pregnant of ended in the show is `` over '' him that ex-wife! Boyfriend wo n't sleep with his child was included in the broadcast version following the commercial.! New girlfriend a stripper, even though they promised not to have bachelor/bachelorette parties would pregnant... Ross 's haircut, Jennifer Aniston: did Friends star Do UNDERBOOB before it was a thing latter causes to. Suddenly got naked and had sex and ended up sleeping together with his child who thinks. Amend the subplot after the 9/11 attacks that there 's a gas leak writings out their together... Go on their honeymoon as Rachel prepares to tell Ross that he has time! 'S a gas leak some time now if she wants to have with. Did Friends star Do UNDERBOOB before it was a thing which would ’ ve brought ’. Then suddenly, a stunned Ross wrestles with choosing her or Julie but Joey ca because... Company instead of talking with Rachel cast: star speaks out on 'disrespectful scene! 'S facing inwards he has some time now if she wants to have with. A bachelorette party with a stripper, even though they promised not to sex... Were writings out their vows together for Monica and Chandler 's personal trainer and Phoebe find that had.